NOTE
Not capital, not foreign currency: The regulatory gap in the application of exchange control regulations to cryptocurrencies in Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v South African Reserve Bank (GP)
Authors: Khodani Sengwane & Zinhle Novazi
ISSN: 1996-2177
Affiliations: Lecturer, University of Pretoria; Lecturer, Stellenbosch University; PhD candidate, University of Groningen
Source: South African Law Journal, Volume 143 Issue 4, p. 676-690
https://doi.org/10.47348/SALJ/v143/i4a3
Abstract
This case note examines Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v South African Reserve Bank 2025 (5) SA 289 (GP), where the High Court held that cryptocurrency is neither ‘foreign currency’ nor ‘capital’ under the Exchange Control Regulations, 1961. The note evaluates the judgment through principles of statutory interpretation, legality and separation of powers, given the Regulations’ forfeiture consequences. The note argues that the court resisted extending an outdated regulatory scheme to cryptocurrency through strained judicial interpretation. Although cryptocurrency may store and transfer value across borders, functional equivalence cannot replace clear legislative authority. The note also briefly considers the subsequent rejection of the Standard Bank case in Mangundhla v South African Reserve Bank [2026] ZAGPJHC 579, which found the Standard Bank case to be wrong and held that Bitcoin constituted both money and capital for purposes of exchange-control regulation. These conflicting judgments accentuate the significant regulatory uncertainty surrounding the applicability of Exchange Control Rules to cryptocurrency. Legislative reform, including the Draft Capital Flow Management Regulations, 2026, offers the constitutionally appropriate means of incorporating cryptocurrencies into South Africa’s capital-flow regime.