NOTE

‘A lattice of rules and exceptions’: An analysis of the foreign act of state doctrine in East Asian Consortium BV v MTN Group Ltd (SCA)

Authors: Ntokozo Dladla & Jane Borman

ISSN: 1996-2177
Affiliations: Lawyer, Open Secrets; Lawyer, Open Secrets
Source: South African Law Journal, Volume 143 Issue 4, p. 691-706
https://doi.org/10.47348/SALJ/v143/i4a4

Abstract

This note examines the ‘weighing of reasons’ test introduced in the Supreme Court of Appeal’s majority decision in East Asian Consortium BV v MTN Group Ltd & others 2025 (5) SA 33 (SCA). We argue that it represents an important development in South African common law, as it provides a novel reconfiguration of the foreign act of state doctrine. By foregrounding the Constitution as it relates to the foreign act of state doctrine, the majority decision detaches the doctrine from its English common-law roots in an attempt to test new limits of the Constitution’s capacity to constrain public and corporate power. Although the majority’s ‘weighing of reasons’ test signals an important move away from English common-law dogma, we argue that it does so by discarding legal certainty in favour of a test that remains too vague and that is hence, arguably, unworkable.